Donation processing · head to head
4aGoodCause vs Givebutter
4aGoodCause and Givebutter both sit in Donation processing. 4aGoodCause: From $99/mo ($1,188/yr, billed annually). Givebutter: Free with donor tips on (0% platform fee). The table below lines up pricing model and fit, each in the product's own terms, so you can see which one matches your shop.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. Disclosure
| 4aGoodCause | Givebutter | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | From $99/mo ($1,188/yr, billed annually) | Free with donor tips on (0% platform fee) |
| Pricing model | Flat subscription; no percentage taken from donations | Tips-on free or flat 3%; processing fees apply; optional Plus tier |
| Best for | Shops that want a payment processor that does not charge per transaction, potentially saving thousands each year. Lighter CRM integration, but great for small shops just taking the next step and looking to cap costs on fees. Plentiful integrations (like Mailchimp and Quickbooks) to make up for fewer built-ins on the CRM. However, the price point justifies this and makes it our top pick for a donor processor. | Fee-sensitive shops that are okay with donors being prompted to tip but who also would like the option to do more robust fundraising down the road. |
| Last verified | Aug 2026 | Aug 2026 |
4aGoodCause
Strengths: Flat subscription with no platform percentage, so the fee stops scaling with your success; Built around monthly giving: recurring pages, donor records and a campaign builder in one tool; Published pricing on every tier, and the first month is free.
Not the fit?
- Raising under about $40,000 a year online? Donorbox →
- Want to pay nothing at all? Zeffy →
Try 4aGoodCauseReader deal through this site$25 in account credit with code 4AGC25
Givebutter
Strengths: Free platform spanning donations, ticketing, auctions, and peer-to-peer; The most modern donor-facing experience among the free options; Clean pricing switch: tips on for 0%, tips off for a flat 3%.
Not the fit?
- Want fees that don't depend on donor behavior? 4aGoodCause →
- Running a large auction? Greater Giving →